Journal

Too Good to Be True

At the River Cafe I ordered the Elton John Zero and was poured Krug by mistake. What the mix-up says about drinks that ask to be compared with Champagne.

The news about Elton John Blanc de Blancs Zero coming to the USA reminded me of a recent visit to the River Cafe in London. After ordering, honestly, too much food (you just can’t escape it at this place), I noticed that they offer the Blanc de Blancs by the glass. I had wanted to try it for quite some time, so I ordered one.

The glass arrived, I tasted it, and I went quiet. It was good. I don’t mean good the way a non-alcoholic “wine alternative” usually is, where you nod, appreciate the effort and file it under “not bad”. This one made me sit up. It had a fineness and a depth I had never found in an “alternative” anything. I should have been pleased. I was suspicious.

I turned to my husband and said, “This is too good to be true.” I meant it literally. Either non-alcoholic wine had made a miraculous leap, or I was drinking something I hadn’t ordered. Still, I hesitated, because you doubt yourself before you doubt the staff. Maybe I had misread the menu. Maybe this really was the state of the art, and I was about to embarrass myself by questioning a perfectly correct pour in one of London’s most beloved dining rooms. So I sat with the glass a little longer, half-hoping to convince myself that the alternative had simply got this good.

In the end the suspicion won, and I asked the waiter to check the order. He came back quickly, with a scared face. What stood on the table was a glass of Krug, poured by mistake. So my palate had been right, and “too good to be true” turned out to be a precise technical assessment.

The story could have ended there, with a polite exchange of glasses. It didn’t, and I won’t pretend otherwise: I drank the Champagne, all of it. There is a limit to how principled one can be with a glass of Krug that is already poured, already tasted and already admired. I had ordered the abstention and been served the temptation, and the only gracious answer to a joke like that is to accept it.

When the Blanc de Blancs Zero eventually arrived, I drank that too, and in fairness it is not that bad. It has one real point in its favour: it is not dealcoholized. Chardonnay must from northern Italy is fermented with bacteria instead.

The conclusion is obvious and slightly ironic. A drink that asks to be compared with Champagne can be perfectly decent and still lose the moment the real thing arrives at the table. The drinks I care about most never ask for that comparison, so a glass of Krug at the next seat takes nothing away from them. They are what I document at Beyond Wine.

As for my palate, it proved a better detective than my mind gives it credit for. When it tells you something is too good to be true, you should listen. And then, perhaps, finish the glass anyway.

The Beyond Wine newsletter

Early chapters, behind-the-scenes notes and tasting invitations.