Too Good to Be True
At the River Cafe I ordered the Elton John Zero and was poured Krug by mistake. What the mix-up says about drinks that ask to be compared with Champagne.
The news about Elton John Blanc de Blancs Zero coming to the USA reminded me of a recent visit to the River Cafe in London. After ordering, honestly, too much food (you just can’t escape it at this place), I noticed that they offer the Blanc de Blancs by the glass. I had wanted to try it for quite some time, so I ordered one.
The glass arrived, I tasted it, and I went quiet. It was good. I don’t mean good the way a non-alcoholic “wine alternative” usually is, where you nod, appreciate the effort and file it under “not bad”. This one made me sit up. It had a fineness and a depth I had never found in an “alternative” anything. I should have been pleased. I was suspicious.
I turned to my husband and said, “This is too good to be true.” I meant it literally. Either non-alcoholic wine had made a miraculous leap, or I was drinking something I hadn’t ordered. Still, I hesitated, because you doubt yourself before you doubt the staff. Maybe I had misread the menu. Maybe this really was the state of the art, and I was about to embarrass myself by questioning a perfectly correct pour in one of London’s most beloved dining rooms. So I sat with the glass a little longer, half-hoping to convince myself that the alternative had simply got this good.
In the end the suspicion won, and I asked the waiter to check the order. He came back quickly, with a scared face. What stood on the table was a glass of Krug, poured by mistake. So my palate had been right, and “too good to be true” turned out to be a precise technical assessment.
The story could have ended there, with a polite exchange of glasses. It didn’t, and I won’t pretend otherwise: I drank the Champagne, all of it. There is a limit to how principled one can be with a glass of Krug that is already poured, already tasted and already admired. I had ordered the abstention and been served the temptation, and the only gracious answer to a joke like that is to accept it.
When the Blanc de Blancs Zero eventually arrived, I drank that too, and in fairness it is not that bad. It has one real point in its favour: it is not dealcoholized. Chardonnay must from northern Italy is fermented with bacteria instead.
The conclusion is obvious and slightly ironic. A drink that asks to be compared with Champagne can be perfectly decent and still lose the moment the real thing arrives at the table. The drinks I care about most never ask for that comparison, so a glass of Krug at the next seat takes nothing away from them. They are what I document at Beyond Wine.
As for my palate, it proved a better detective than my mind gives it credit for. When it tells you something is too good to be true, you should listen. And then, perhaps, finish the glass anyway.